I was at yoga. My first real outing postpartum that didn’t involve a pharmacy run for nipple cream or a panic-driven pediatrician visit. My friend and I were in the lobby, buzzing about how my husband was home with the baby and how, thanks to nap scheduling actually working, I had a free hour.

That’s when she appeared: PTA Susan.

She leaned over with that fake “I’m just concerned” voice and said: “Three months is awfully young to be doing all that scheduling. My babies napped on me until they were at least two. That’s how they knew they could trust me.”

I came to work on my flexibility, not my self-restraint. Unfortunately, I ended up practicing both.

The Mom Advice Hell-Hole Is Real

The moment you start feeling even slightly confident about your baby’s sleep, it’s like a signal goes out. Suddenly everyone has an opinion. At the park. In the grocery store checkout line. In that Facebook group you swore you’d “just lurk” in.

“We never scheduled our babies, and they turned out fine.”

“If you don’t contact nap until age two, your baby won’t feel safe.”

“Crying for even five minutes will cause permanent emotional damage.”

“Schedules are for control freaks who don’t love their kids enough to let them lead.”

That last one is my favorite. Because nothing says “I love my baby” like keeping them awake for six hours straight until they collapse face-down into their mashed peas.

Why the Unsolicited Advice Hits So Hard

It’s not the advice itself. It’s the timing. These comments always find you right before you’re starting to feel momentum. You are on the verge of your first one good nap, one longer stretch at night, one morning where you didn’t cry before coffee. And someone swoops in to tell you you’re doing it wrong.

The reason it works is because new moms are already drowning in guilt. You don’t need Susan to pour more on top. You’re already wondering if the crying is too much, if the schedule is too rigid, if you should just give in because it would be easier.

Easier for tonight. Catastrophic for next month.

The Part They Don’t Tell You About Their Method

Here’s what PTA Susan didn’t mention: her two-year-old still doesn’t sleep through the night. Her marriage is hanging by a thread because neither parent has slept more than four consecutive hours in twenty-four months. She hasn’t been to yoga in a year because she can’t leave the house without her kid losing it.

But sure, her baby “trusts” her.

Trust isn’t built by never letting your child experience discomfort. Trust is built by showing up consistently, responding predictably, and yes, sometimes letting them figure things out while you’re right there, watching, ready.

What I Wish I’d Said Back

“Thanks, but my baby sleeps 8 hours a night and naps like clockwork. I have my mental health back, my marriage back, and this free hour that I’m spending here instead of bouncing a screaming baby in a dark room. So I’m good.”

That’s what I wish I’d said. What I actually said was “hm” and then unrolled my yoga mat with slightly too much force.

Your Plan Is Not Up for Public Debate

If you have a plan and it’s working, you don’t owe anyone an explanation. Not Susan. Not your mother-in-law. Not the pediatrician who casually says “whatever works for your family” while offering zero actionable advice.

I’m writing Mom Awakened because I needed this book and it didn’t exist. A book that doesn’t hedge. Doesn’t “well, every baby is different” you to death. Doesn’t present seven contradictory methods and leave you to figure it out alone at midnight. It’s the book that says: here’s the plan, here’s why, and here’s exactly how to hold the line when Susan comes for you.

---

Clara Harper is a children’s book author, sleep training evangelist, and the person at yoga who almost said something but didn’t. Her memoir Mom Interrupted is available wherever books are sold. She’s on TikTok being less polite than she was to Susan.

Teaching your little one to handle big feelings? Check out Anxiety Is My Monster for kids who need help naming what’s happening inside.